- Forward osmosis is not dead – interview with leading water consultant Walid Khoury - August 30, 2020
- Listing of major commercial & academic FO players on ForwardOsmosisTech - April 12, 2020
- 0.26MGD FO-SWRO Hybrid for seawater desalination achieves 25% energy reduction compared to MF/SWRO - December 14, 2019
The main challenge with today’s water treatment technologies
Today’s water treatment technologies are effective but not always efficient. As a result, considerably more energy will be needed to replenish ever dwindling fresh water resources in the near future, however, less energy will be available to do so. One potential solution to this challenge is forward osmosis based water treatment systems.
Why water and energy are two sides of the same coin
In today’s world where energy prices are increasing, due to over-utilization of fossil fuels, and fresh water resources are declining, energy efficient water treatment technologies are becoming increasingly important for sustained global development. This is especially true because of the linkage of water and energy in what has been coined the water-energy nexus, where – on one hand – water is required in all forms of energy production (either in the energy production process itself or to generate raw materials), and – on the other hand – energy is required for all forms of water treatment.
Energy efficiency in water treatment processes
The water-energy nexus drives development of ever more efficient water treatment technologies. However, traditional pressure driven membrane technologies, such as reverse osmosis, nanofiltration, ultrafiltration, and microfiltration, are reaching their efficiency limits. As an example, McGovern et. al. recently treated the topic of energy consumption in seawater desalination processes (McGovern et. al., JMS, 2014). Here, the theoretical energy requirement for direct desalination of seawater (35000ppm, 50% recovery) is reported at 1,05 kWh/m^3. Throughout the last 30 years of research into improving the efficiency of reverse osmosis technologies, current RO systems are able to desalinate seawater at 47% thermodynamic efficiency corresponding to an energy usage of 2,34 kWh/m^3. Researchers agree that this number will be very hard to improve significantly in the future, and similar arguments apply for nanofiltration, ultrafiltration, and microfiltration technologies.
New technologies: forward osmosis
Hence, in order to radically improve the efficiency of water treatment systems, new technologies are needed. One such technology, which has been gaining increasing interest the last 10 years, is forward osmosis. According to ForwardOsmosisTech, forward osmosis is “the process of spontaneous water diffusion across a semi-permeable forward osmosis membrane in response to a difference in solute concentrations (i.e. osmotic pressures) on either side of the semi-permeable membrane”. The figure below shows a schematic diagram of a forward osmosis process in action.
Since forward osmosis processes are driven by osmotic pressure and not energy-consuming hydraulic pressures, the process of water diffusion across a forward osmosis membrane comes at zero energy costs. In fact, all that is needed – in form of energy usage – to operate a forward osmosis system is pumps for circulating feed and draw solutions across either side of the membrane. Researchers (McGovern et. al., JMOS, 2014 and McGinnis et. al, Desalination, 2007) have estimated the energy usage in forward osmosis systems to be in the region 0,16 kWh/m^2 to 0,25 kWh/m^3. This is one tenth of the energy usage of RO systems for desalination of seawater.
The sweet spot for forward osmosis-based water treatment systems
In order for forward osmosis-based water treatment systems to maximize energy savings, industrial applications must be found where the forward osmosis system can operate alone without the need for auxiliary pressure driven sub-systems. In essence, such stand-alone forward osmosis systems, perform low-energy water exchange from a low concentration stream to a high concentration stream, thus, resulting in two value generators for the end user:
- Concentration of a low concentration stream
- Dilution of a high concentration stream
These value generators are extremely useful for industrial process optimization in factories / plants where concentration of low concentration streams and dilution of high concentration streams are handled separately. Examples of such factories / plants can readily be found in the oil & gas industry, the textile industry, and the white biotech industry.
To further clarify the energy saving potential of forward osmosis-based water treatment systems, imagine a factory with a process stream that must be diluted with fresh water before down stream processing can take place (the concentrate (draw) arrow in the figure below). The same factory has a difficult wastewater stream that is dewatered in an energy-intensive system containing both reverse osmosis membranes and evaporators (the dilutate (feed) arrow) in the figure below).
By combining said process streams in a forward osmosis-based water treatment system, the factory gains savings on two levels:
- Reduction of fresh water usage for dilution
- Reduction of energy usage for concentration
What does the future hold for forward osmosis-based water treatment systems?
There are already a hand-full companies working hard to commercialize forward osmosis technologies in various industrial applications. However, so far, broad market adoption has been limited. Mainly because of a lack of available system capacity as well as real-life case studies where the forward osmosis value proposition has been proven. I expect this picture to change in the near future as more test-bedding is completed and forward osmosis membrane manufacturers are successful in up-scaling their production capacity.
NB: post thumbnail image from IWMI, 2000